File a Claim

Claims can be reported during normal business hours by calling our Main Office at (315) 598-6000 or toll free at (800) 836-3324. For after hours access, click on your carrier link below to visit their website directly.

Acadia Insurance
Claims: 1 (800) 773-4300
Service: 1 (800) 773-4300
Claims Billing Website
American Collectors Insurance
Claims: 1 (800) 360-2277
Service: 1 (800) 360-2277
Claims Billing Website
American Modern
Claims: 1 (800) 375-2075
Service: 1 (800) 543-2644
Claims Billing Website
AmTrust Financial
Claims: 1 (866) 272-9267
Service: 1 (877) 528-7878
Claims Billing Website
The Cincinnati Insurance Companies
Claims: 1 (877) 242-2544
Service: 1 (877) 242-2544
Claims Billing Website
CNA Surety
Claims: 1 (877) 672-6115
Service: 1 (800) 331-6053
Claims Billing Website
Comp Alliance
Claims: 1 (516) 750-9474
Service: 1 (516) 750-9474
Claims Billing Website
Countryway Insurance Company
Claims: 1 (888) 223-3649
Service: 1 (888) 223-3649
Claims Billing Website
Dryden Mutual
Claims: 1 (800) 782-0154
Service: 1 (800) 724-0560
Claims Billing Website
Eastern Mutual
Claims: 1 (800) 367-3242
Service: 1 (800) 367-3242
Claims Billing Website
Emergency Services Insurance Program (ESIP)
Claims: 1 (800) 822-3747
Service: 1 (800) 822-3747
Claims Billing Website
Encompass
Claims: 1 (800) 588-7400
Service: 1 (800) 262-7255
Claims Billing Website
Erie and Niagara Insurance Association
Claims: 1 (716) 632-5433
Service: 1 (866) 587-9820
Claims Billing Website
Foremost Insurance Group
Claims: 1 (800) 527-3907
Service: 1 (800) 527-3905
Claims Billing Website
Great American Insurance Group
Claims: 1 (800) 475-2691
Service: 1 (800) 545-4269
Claims Billing Website
GuideOne Insurance
Claims: 1 (888) 748-4326
Service: 1 (877) 448-4331
Claims Billing Website
Hagerty
Claims: 1 (877) 922-9701
Service: 1 (877) 922-9701
Claims Billing Website
Harleysville
Claims: 1 (800) 421-3535
Service: 1 (800) 338-8301
Claims Billing Website
The Hartford
Claims: 1 (800) 243-5860
Service: 1 (860) 547-5000
Claims Billing Website
The Hartford Steam Boiler
Claims: 1 (888) 472-5677
Service: 1 (800) 472-1866
Claims Billing Website
J.C. Taylor Specialty Automobile Insurance
Claims: 1 (800) 272-6764
Service: 1 (800) 345-8290
Claims Billing Website
K&K Insurance Group
Claims: 1 (800) 237-2917
Service: 1 (800) 637-4757
Claims Billing Website
Liberty Mutual Insurance
Claims: 1 (800) 225-2467
Service: 1 (888) 398-8924
Claims Billing Website
Madison Mutual Insurance
Claims: 315-687-3211
Service: 315-687-3211
Claims Billing Website
Mainstreet America Group
Claims: 1 (877) 425-2467
Service: 1 (800) 258-5310
Claims Billing Website
McNeil & Co
Claims: 1 (800) 822-3747
Service: 1 (800) 814-4447
Claims Billing Website
Michigan Millers
Claims: 1 (877) 858-5361
Service: 1 (800) 888-1914
Claims Billing Website
Midstate Mutual Insurance Company
Claims: 1 (800) 826-8520
Service: 1 (800) 826-8520
Claims Billing Website
National General Insurance
Claims: 1 (800) 325-1088
Service: 1 (888) 293-5108
Claims Billing Website
Nationwide
Claims: 1 (800) 421-3535
Service: 1 (877) 669-6877
Claims Billing Website
New York Municipal Insurance Reciprocal (NYMIR)
Claims: 1 (516) 227-2300
Service: 1 (516) 465-7552
Claims Billing Website
New York Schools Insurance Reciprocal (NYSIR)
Claims: 1 (800) 476-9747
Service: 1 (800) 476-9747
Claims Billing Website
North Country Insurance Company
Claims: 1 (800) 847-7030
Service: 1 (800) 847-7030
Claims Billing Website
NYCM Insurance
Claims: 1 (800) 234-6926
Service: 1 (800) 234-6926
Claims Billing Website
Ontario Insurance Company
Claims: 1 (585) 289-9560
Service: 1 (585) 289-9560
Claims Billing Website
Oswego County Mutual
Claims: 1 (800) 640-9660
Service: 1 (800) 640-9660
Claims Billing Website
PERMA
Claims: 1 (888) 737-6269
Service: 1 (888) 737-6269
Claims Billing Website
Philadelphia Insurance Companies
Claims: 1 (800) 765-9749
Service: 1 (877) 438-7459
Claims Billing Website
Preferred Mutual
Claims: 1 (800) 333-7642
Service: 1 (800) 333-7642
Claims Billing Website
Progressive
Claims: 1 (800) 274-4499
Service: 1 (855) 758-0943
Claims Billing Website
Safeco Insurance
Claims: 1 (800) 332-3226
Service: 1 (800) 332-3226
Claims Billing Website
Selective Insurance (Business Insurance)
Claims: 1 (866) 455-9969
Service: 1 (800) 735-3284
Claims Billing Website
Sterling Insurance
Claims: 1 (518) 234-2521
Service: 1 (518) 234-2521
Claims Billing Website
Travelers
Claims: 1 (800) 238-6225
Service: 1 (800) 842-5075
Claims Billing Website
USLI
Claims: 1 (888) 875-5231
Service: 1 (888) 523-5545
Claims Billing Website
Utica National Insurance Group
Claims: 1 (800) 216-1420
Service: 1 (781) 224-2600
Claims Billing Website
Volunteer Firemen's Insurance Service
Claims: 1 (800) 233-1957
Service: 1 (717) 741-0911
Claims Billing Website
Wayne Cooperative Insurance Company
Claims: 1 (800) 724-1648
Service: 1 (800) 724-1648
Claims Billing Website
Wright Flood Insurance
Claims: 1 (800) 725-9472
Service: 1 (800) 820-3242
Claims Billing Website
Zurich Insurance
Claims: 1 (800) 987-3373
Service: 1 (800) 382-2150
Claims Billing Website